---

title: "Maintaining Your Historic Massachusetts Home" description: "Owning a historic home on the South Shore is a privilege. These colonials, capes, Victorians, and farmhouses tell the story of Massachusetts history, from the e" date: "2025-02-12" category: "Home Styles" tags: ["historic homes","preservation","maintenance","old houses","restoration"] author: "Zeke"

Maintaining Your Historic Massachusetts Home

A guide for owners of pre-1950 homes on the South Shore

Owning a historic home on the South Shore is a privilege. These colonials, capes, Victorians, and farmhouses tell the story of Massachusetts history, from the early settlements through the industrial age. They have craftsmanship you simply do not find in modern construction: hand-hewn beams, original hardwood floors, plaster walls with character, and architectural details that make each home unique.

But with that character comes responsibility. Historic homes have different maintenance needs than modern construction, and some of the systems and materials in older homes require special knowledge to maintain safely. This guide covers what you need to know about caring for your pre-1950 South Shore home.

Why Historic Homes Need Special Attention

Built for a Different Era

Homes built before 1950 were designed for different lifestyles, different technology, and different energy costs:

• Heating: Many were built before central heating, designed to be heated room by room with fireplaces or coal stoves
• Insulation: Minimal or none; they relied on multiple layers and small rooms to retain heat
• Electricity: Often added after construction, sometimes in ways that do not meet modern standards
• Plumbing: May have been retrofitted, potentially with mixed materials and improvised routing

Materials That Age Differently

Historic homes contain materials rarely used today, some of which require special handling:

• Lead paint (common until 1978)
• Asbestos (insulation, tiles, siding - common 1920s-1970s)
• Knob and tube wiring (common until 1940s)
• Galvanized steel or lead pipes
• Original plaster walls and ceilings
• Old-growth lumber (actually better than modern lumber in many ways)

Continuous Maintenance Required

Modern homes are designed to be relatively maintenance-free for years at a time. Historic homes were built expecting regular maintenance. Skip the upkeep, and small problems become large ones quickly.

Hazardous Materials: What You Need to Know

Lead Paint

The reality: If your home was built before 1978, it almost certainly has lead paint somewhere, usually under layers of newer paint.

When it is dangerous: Lead paint that is intact and covered by newer paint is generally not a hazard. It becomes dangerous when it deteriorates (chalking, peeling, chipping) or when it is disturbed by renovation.

What to do:

• Do not sand, scrape, or disturb old paint without precautions
• If paint is peeling, keep children and pets away from the area
• Hire EPA-certified lead-safe renovators for any work that disturbs painted surfaces
• Consider professional testing before major renovation projects

For families with young children: Get a lead risk assessment, especially for window wells, porches, and exterior soil where lead dust accumulates.

Cost note: Lead testing costs $200-400. Lead-safe renovation adds 10-30% to project costs. Lead abatement (full removal) can cost thousands and is usually not necessary unless paint is actively deteriorating.

Asbestos

Where it hides: Asbestos was used in many building materials:

• Pipe insulation (gray/white fibrous wrap)
• Boiler insulation
• Floor tiles (especially 9x9 inch tiles)
• Some siding materials
• Popcorn ceilings (1950s-1980s)
• Some plaster and joint compounds

When it is dangerous: Like lead, intact asbestos that is not disturbed is generally not an immediate hazard. It becomes dangerous when fibers are released into the air through damage or renovation.

What to do:

• Do not disturb suspected asbestos materials
• Get professional testing before renovation ($200-400 per sample)
• If asbestos is found: leave it alone (encapsulate) or hire licensed abatement professionals
• Never attempt DIY asbestos removal

South Shore note: Many colonials in Hingham, Cohasset, and surrounding towns have asbestos pipe wrap in basements. If it is in good condition, the safest approach is often to leave it alone.

Knob and Tube Wiring

What it is: The standard wiring method from the 1880s through the 1940s. Individual wires run through porcelain "knobs" (which hold them away from framing) and "tubes" (which protect them through joists).

Is it dangerous? Knob and tube wiring itself is not inherently unsafe. It becomes dangerous when:

• Insulation is blown over it (causes overheating)
• It has been modified improperly
• Connections have deteriorated
• It is overloaded with modern electrical demands

What to do:

• Have an electrician experienced with historic homes evaluate your system
• Never cover knob and tube with insulation
• Watch for signs of problems: flickering lights, warm outlets, tripped breakers
• Plan for eventual rewiring, but it may not be urgent if the system is in good condition

Insurance note: Some insurers will not cover homes with active knob and tube wiring, or charge higher premiums. Check with your insurer.

Rewiring cost: Full rewiring of a South Shore colonial typically runs $15,000-30,000 depending on access and home size.

Preserving Character While Updating Systems

The challenge of historic home ownership is balancing preservation with modern comfort and safety. Here is how to approach common updates.

Windows

The dilemma: Original wood windows are part of your home's character and often better made than modern replacements. But they can be drafty and inefficient.

Best approach:

• Restore and weatherize original windows rather than replace
• Add storm windows (traditional wood storms preserve appearance)
• Use rope caulk or weatherstripping to address drafts
• Only replace if windows are beyond repair

Why this matters: Properly restored original windows with storm windows can perform nearly as well as new windows, at lower cost, while preserving your home's character and value.

Cost: Window restoration: $200-500 per window. High-quality replacement: $800-1,500+ per window.

Insulation

The challenge: Historic homes were built without insulation, and adding it incorrectly can cause serious problems (moisture damage, rot, paint failure).

Safe approaches:

• Attic insulation (usually straightforward, but avoid covering knob and tube)
• Basement rim joist insulation
• Weatherstripping and air sealing (the most impactful improvement for most homes)

Risky approaches:

• Blown-in wall insulation can trap moisture and cause rot in homes not designed for it
• Dense-packing walls requires careful analysis of vapor barriers and drying potential

Recommendation: Consult with a building science professional who understands historic construction before adding wall insulation.

Heating Systems

Common upgrades:

• Replacing an old boiler or furnace with a high-efficiency unit
• Adding central AC (requires careful ductwork planning in old homes)
• Converting from oil to gas or heat pumps

Preservation considerations:

• Keep original radiators if possible (they often work better than modern baseboard)
• Avoid interior ductwork that damages plaster ceilings and walls
• Consider mini-splits for AC (no ductwork required)

Plumbing

Common issues in pre-1950 homes:

• Galvanized steel pipes (corrode from inside, reduce water pressure)
• Lead supply lines (rare but possible)
• Mixed materials (steel, copper, and sometimes lead)
• Undersized drain lines

Upgrade approach:

• Replace galvanized steel with copper or PEX as it fails
• Consider whole-house repiping if multiple sections are failing
• Test for lead if you have any concerns

Electrical

Beyond knob and tube, older homes often have:

• Insufficient outlets (people ran fewer devices)
• Two-prong ungrounded outlets
• Undersized service panel (60 or 100 amp)

Priority upgrades:

• GFCI protection in bathrooms, kitchen, and outdoors
• Grounded outlets where electronics are used
• Panel upgrade if you need more capacity

Maintenance Schedule for Historic Homes

Historic homes need more frequent attention than modern homes.

Annually

• Inspect roof for damaged or missing materials
• Check all flashing (chimney, dormers, valleys)
• Inspect foundation for cracks or water intrusion
• Check basement for moisture and pests
• Inspect attic for leaks, pests, and insulation condition
• Clean chimneys (if used)
• Check exterior paint condition
• Inspect and clean gutters (twice yearly is better)

Every 3-5 Years

• Touch up exterior paint where needed
• Recaulk windows and doors as needed
• Service wood windows (lubricate, adjust)
• Inspect and treat any wood rot
• Have electrical system checked by qualified electrician
• Inspect plumbing for corrosion

Every 10-15 Years

• Full exterior repaint
• Roof replacement (slate can last 100+ years; asphalt 20-30)
• Major system replacements as needed

Working with Contractors on Historic Homes

Not all contractors understand historic construction. The wrong approach can cause serious damage.

What to look for:

• Experience with pre-1950 homes specifically
• Understanding of historic materials (plaster, wood, lime mortar)
• Willingness to repair rather than replace
• Knowledge of local historic district requirements (if applicable)

Red flags:

• "We'll just rip that out and start fresh"
• No experience with lead and asbestos protocols
• One-size-fits-all approach to insulation or weatherization
• Pressure to replace original features

Finding good contractors:

• Ask neighbors with similar homes
• Contact local historic preservation organizations
• Check with your town's historical commission

Historic Districts and Regulations

Some South Shore communities have local historic districts or individual historic designations:

• Hingham has multiple National Register historic districts
• Cohasset has protected historic areas
• Scituate has designated historic properties

If your home is in a historic district:

• Exterior changes may require approval from the local historical commission
• There may be restrictions on windows, siding, roofing materials, and paint colors
• Additions and alterations need to be compatible with the historic character

Benefits:

• Property values in historic districts often appreciate more
• Tax incentives may be available for preservation work
• Community of neighbors who care about maintenance and appearance

The Value of Preservation

Maintaining a historic home properly is an investment that pays returns:

Financial:

• Well-maintained historic homes command premium prices
• Original features (hardwood, plaster, architectural details) are selling points
• Deferred maintenance destroys value faster in old homes

Practical:

• Original materials often last longer than modern replacements
• Historic construction methods are proven over centuries
• Quality craftsmanship is hard to replicate today

Intangible:

• You are preserving Massachusetts history
• Your home has stories to tell
• There is satisfaction in stewardship

Getting Started

If you have recently purchased a historic South Shore home, here is where to begin:

1. Document what you have: Photograph original features, note materials, understand what previous owners have changed
2. Test for hazards: Get lead and asbestos testing before any renovation
3. Evaluate major systems: Have heating, electrical, and plumbing professionally assessed
4. Prioritize safety and water intrusion: Address any active leaks, electrical hazards, or structural concerns first
5. Learn your home's history: Town records, historical societies, and sometimes even previous owners can provide valuable context

---

Historic homes are full of questions. What year was that addition built? Is this original to the house? Should I repair or replace? Can I insulate this wall? Every historic home is different, and generic advice only goes so far. Ask Zeke about your specific home, your specific concerns, and your specific projects. We will help you preserve your home's character while keeping it safe and comfortable for modern living.